I'm no expert, and most members know a lot more than I do, but from my experience, hubs can be picky about what you grease them with, and I have found that different factors can affect breaking speed in coaster brake hubs. I had an off brand Durex? hub which I loaded with grease and That was a TERRIBLE idea. It gave me constant problems after I cleaned and relubed it... it skipped without warning (disengaged mometarily, always while in drive. Very dangerous, caused me to fall off or lose balance quite a few times, always while I was cruising at a good speed). The hub would also take several revolutions of the chainring to re-engage/drive after I relubed it- it never did this before lubrication. I relubed it with bicycle grease, not with automotive grade. I hear that automotive grade lubricant causes problems too... I've heard that heavy lubricants intended for automobiles can make a coster brake almost inoperable (painfully slow stopping). My hub was fixed after I removed all the grease and put SAE 30 motor oil in these instead Motor oil went on all the braking surfaces and driver threads; the bearings I greased). That seems to be the magic lubricant. The old service manuals for Model D New Departure's tell you to use SAE 20 oil on certain parts and bicycle grease on others... I follow these specific directions very carefully but use SAE30 instead of SAE20 and find that this gives you a quick (but not too quick) stop. As someone mentioned above, chain tension affects stop time, too. I find that when the hubs are loose they tend to stop a little slower... The best way to learn what affects your hub and stop time is by trial and error I guess. Best of luck. :mrgreen:
I do believe that different lubricants affect brake effectiveness, I also believe from my own personal experience that you have to be careful what you use grease on. However, I can't imagine grease could ever harm anything, so anything is worth a try. At worst you'll have to relubricate the hub and try again. If you need a good hub refernce book, I'd buy "The Big Book of Vintage Bicycle Hubs". I own a copy ot this book and find it very useful. It is full of exploded views, service directions, and step-by-step pictures. It covers quite a few different hub models and makes. I believe a copy of this book can be purchased from the bookstore on theCABE.