From memory: The catalogs from about '36-'39 say 'all full size Elgins come with Alemite lubrication', '40 mentions Alemite...but doesn't say all, '41 doesn't mention Alemite.
Frames like Mazdaflyer's have an Elgin badge, and no zerks (I've seen a couple). So, either some slipped through the cracks and the catalog statement isn't entirely true...or...the bike was rebadged. I would think it's more plausible that some slipped through without zerks, maybe due to running out of zerks...or possibly replacement frames...or maybe some low end or special non-standard model.
Does it matter? Nope. However, a non-badged frame being called an Elgin without zerks makes me ask...'why do you think it is an Elgin?'... because, it's probably not as it doesn't have zerks.
If it was called a Derby or Mercury or Collegiate or Western Flyer, etc, without a badge I would still ask the question...but have no way of disputing the claim.
Why not just call it a Murray? Regardless of which brand it was initially sold as...it's still a Murray.
There are quite a few folk out there that treat Hawthorne and Elgin as manufacturers, when they are just brand names... probably why I tend to comment when it appears they are being used that way. It would be like calling your bike a Berry Cohen Special, because it has a jiffy stand on it...I mean, it's possible, I suppose...but probably not.
It's a cool frame by any name...these '38 to '42 Murray built frames are some of my favorites. In general, pre-war Murray just had a lot of great designs.
Frames like Mazdaflyer's have an Elgin badge, and no zerks (I've seen a couple). So, either some slipped through the cracks and the catalog statement isn't entirely true...or...the bike was rebadged. I would think it's more plausible that some slipped through without zerks, maybe due to running out of zerks...or possibly replacement frames...or maybe some low end or special non-standard model.
Does it matter? Nope. However, a non-badged frame being called an Elgin without zerks makes me ask...'why do you think it is an Elgin?'... because, it's probably not as it doesn't have zerks.
If it was called a Derby or Mercury or Collegiate or Western Flyer, etc, without a badge I would still ask the question...but have no way of disputing the claim.
Why not just call it a Murray? Regardless of which brand it was initially sold as...it's still a Murray.
There are quite a few folk out there that treat Hawthorne and Elgin as manufacturers, when they are just brand names... probably why I tend to comment when it appears they are being used that way. It would be like calling your bike a Berry Cohen Special, because it has a jiffy stand on it...I mean, it's possible, I suppose...but probably not.
It's a cool frame by any name...these '38 to '42 Murray built frames are some of my favorites. In general, pre-war Murray just had a lot of great designs.