Don't you still got to have a battery there? We do here, lights have to stay lit up at rest.
Either way is better than the tire popper!
Decent lights these days have a capacitor built in. My tail-light says lit for at least 5 minutes after I park it. Headlight stays on for probably2 or 3 minutes. The only problem I have is, if I lock a bike with that kinda light up, well-wishing passers-by will switch it to "off" and it confuses the bejeezus out of me when I start rolling and it doesn't light up.
Hub generators are cool but even with the lights off there's always a little drag. Long distance roadies used to run a rub type generator, but instead of the typical grinder bit, they'd have about a three inch diameter rubber wheel which increased the leverage and surface area, thus allowing a lot less spring tension. Haven't seen any lately though. A friend bought me a high end lithium powered light for Christmas a while back and it absolutely
ROCKS!!! Low setting is brighter than most bike lights, and lasts something like 20 hrs on a full charge. High setting is nearly as bright as a Buick headlight, and it has built in strobe and SOS settings as well.
I know a lot of ppl who run battery lights and love'm, but it gets my goat that I'm creating all this power, just by pedaling and rolling, that's going to waste. Plus, i'd be really steamed if I ran out of juice during a ride.... and I'm not the type who'd be diligent about keeping rechargables charged up.... So, hub dynamos are where it's at.
It's true that, technically, the hubs will always have drag, even if the lights are "off". These new hubs, though, are so low drag, it won't make a difference for your commute times or anything like that. There are super-high end hubs that create almost zero drag (like the Schmidt SON, which at about $300, better not have any drag), but even the cheaper Sturmey/SRAM/Shimano offerings produce no discernible drag, as measured by my rear-end as I ride one of my generator-hub equipped bikes right before/after I ride one of my regular-hub bikes.
These new hubs produce so little drag, almost any roadie who needs a light will run something battery operated, or a generator hub. At this point, the bottle doodads are for retro ppl, ppl who really ove their existing hubs, and ppl who can't afford a generator hub. The
Randoneuring ranndon renddaneer **guys who ride long distances and try to pass for French seem smitten with the SON hub, and folks with less scratch tend to make do with any of the lower-cost competitors. From my understanding, all the generator hubs that retail for less than $150 have the electric components made by a Japanese firm called Sanyo; a basic Sanyo "dynamo" hub can be had for, like, $45.
http://peterwhitecycles.com/sanyo.asp
Peter White, who sells a lot of dynamo stuff, from entry-level to the highest of high-end, thinks the Sanyos are really good. If you click the link, scroll down and check out what he has to say about drag....
-Rob
**I'm just playing; I know how to spell "randonneur". I like t call it "audax", like the Brits do, just to rattle the fake-French guys' cage a little bit....